Selecting Band Tunes

[EquusRacer]

While this topic could be in other places (e.g., Music), I'll start it here, for it pertains to those, like P/Ms or others, who pick tunes for the band.

By what criteria do you select tunes for the band? And is this done seasonally, periodically, etc.? One may have to split this topic into single tunes for the tune list (e.g., marches) vs. those for medleys, QMSs, MSRs, and other sets. But back to the question:

Do you consider the grade, nature of the band? Are there other factors, such as the difficulty level, the sight reading capability of most of the members, etc.? Do you have a limited number of tunes per season? And if so, do you "rotate" (i.e., do you keep a limited number of tunes, and therefore replace some with a new tune? I ask that because I've seen far too many lower grade bands that have a ridiculously large list of tunes...consequently, never really able to practice and polish all appropriately).

Do you keep a sort of balance of tunes (e.g., a variety of time signatures, or varied marches and dance tunes, etc.)? Do you work with the Drum Sergeant or the drum corps when you're looking at tunes? (I do, by the way, for our drum corps is important, and it is vital that pipers learn to listen to the drummers, especially when there is a good score for each tune). Are there other factors or practices in your selection?

[Jim Fogelman]

G3 band. We switch out one competition set (medley and MSR) each season, so we only have one new set to learn at a time.

As for tune selection, there are a handful of us who find tunes and share with each other to decide what we like and what we don’t like (with the PM getting the final say). If there are tunes with complicated embellishments, we either leave that tune out or augment the embellishments to something the whole pipe corps can play.

One thing that I, personally, look for is tunes in a variety of keys. A few years ago, the back half of our medley was all in A and sounded kind of boring. With MSRs, I try to have the overall keys of each piece come to an authentic cadence (V-I) so something like M in D, S in E, R in A (overall progression of IV-V-I) which I feel helps the set flow from tune to tune during transitions.

[pancelticpiper]

Originally Posted by Jim Fogelman

One thing that I, personally, look for is tunes in a variety of keys.

I do to. It amazes me how many pipers are key-deaf, and will put together a set of three 4/4s all in A Major.

Or three sets of three 4/4s all in A Major.

Originally Posted by Jim Fogelman

I try to have the overall keys of each piece come to an authentic cadence (V-I) so something like M in D, S in E, R in A (overall progression of IV-V-I) which I feel helps the set flow from tune to tune during transitions.

I understand the thinking, which makes sense, but I wonder how many tunes in the key of E there are. (Yes there are plenty of tunes in A that begin and/or end on the 5th, which is a different kettle of fish.)

I'm not so ambitious, I'm just happy to break things up such as using the ABA format (in the sense of "thing one" into "thing two" then return to "thing one").

It could literally be ABA as in A Major > B minor > A Major or it could be pretty much any two contrasting keys.

One thing I find interesting is the way that in Irish Traditional Music they often put together three-tune sets (the standard number) in contrasting keys, while in Cape Breton fiddling they will often stay in the same key but have contrasting modes.

For example "taking away sharps" by going

A Major > A Mixoldyian > A dorian (or A minor).

I've found that this can be very effective in Highland piping, by starting with a tune in A that lacks the 7th degree and which is perceived as being in A Major by the listener, then going into a tune in A with prominent G notes (the so-called A>G tunes), then going into a tune in A that lacks the 3rd degree which the listener perceives as minor.

To be clear, tunes in these scales, all having A as the tonic:

A B C# D E F# a

G A B C# D E F# g a

G A B D E g a

In ITM a three-tune formula I've found that sounds good almost no matter which tunes you plug into it is the rising tonic, the medley going

D Major > E minor > G Major

The equivalent on the Highland pipes would be

A Major > B minor > D Major.

BTW for competition music I try to avoid tunes in D like the plague. Especially I don't want to end a medley on the note D. Even when Grade One bands do it, that last D is rarely perfectly in tune.

[pancelticpiper]

Originally Posted by EquusRacer

By what criteria do you select tunes for the band?

Do you consider the grade, nature of the band?

I think any PM that doesn't consider the band's playing level is setting himself up for trouble.

Years ago I attended a practice of a Grade 3 band and they handed out a tune of a very high level of complexity, a tune that only a circle composed of Grade One players could handle.

I said something about the suitability of the setting. The Pipe Major looked at me like I had horns growing out of my head and said "this is the actual sheet music from _______ " (a Worlds-winning Grade One band).

Oh dear me.

My idea about suitability of settings may sound crazy, but I think it's entirely practical. I don't think a band should play a setting that the band's worst plper on his worst day on a hot afternoon in the sun in his eyes and a beer in his belly can't play well.

But no, bands will choose settings that only the top couple pipers in the band can play well, on their best day, in ideal circumstances.

Notice I say "settings" rather than "tunes". As I've been told "there are no difficult tunes, only difficult settings."

Originally Posted by EquusRacer

do you keep a limited number of tunes? I've seen far too many lower grade bands that have a ridiculously large list of tunes...

That's true for sure. I know many lower-level pipers who forget how to play tunes that they don't practice regularly, and many higher-level pipers who can dredge up tunes that they've not played in 30 years and make a decent go of them. I know it's not always like that, but in general my experience has been that it behooves lower-level bands to have smaller repertoires.

Most of the competition bands I've been in keep small tune-lists, often only their competition sets and Massed Bands tunes.

Or they might also maintain a parade set or two, or a show set or two.

(Sorry for using masculine pronouns, but as English lacks gender-neutral ones I did it to save space and make the sentences flow better.)

[Pip01]

Originally Posted by pancelticpiper

I don't think a band should play a setting that the band's worst plper on his worst day on a hot afternoon in the sun in his eyes and a beer in his belly can't play well.

Greetings to All,


Well... And there... you have it !! :)

Once and again... this particular "nail"... actually a great
metal spike!!... has been stunningly struck!!... and upon its
quite... and all too obvious... leering head!! :)

And... this "consideration"... 'cause it most certainly ain't...
a rule!!... should be embraced... by many solo players... as
well. :) (The "consideration" part of this is for we poor sods...
who are on the listening end... of this particular stick. :)

Would any... mount a horse... that they may not... be able to
ride??

Would any... enter a cockpit... of a plane... that they may not...
be able to fly??

But one of our... ever present... and on-going... circumstances...
that so beset us all... Poor Mortal Sods... is our seemingly and
ever infinite... facility... for self-delusion... :) ('Twas ever thus. :)

Now... I am ever for... Aiming Up!! :) ... and... Getting Better!!...
but that is why... practice sessions... away from The Public... are
enjoined upon us... so that "the others"... are saved from having
to be subjected to... all of the musical discombobulations... that
in our playing we must endure... and through which we must all
slog... until that elusive harmony... is properly birthed... and then...
brought forth... :)

All such... was always... a tough go... but please... let us all have
that... and such... "consideration"... so that The Music... is the
better heard... and so... the more greatly... appreciated... :)

Warmest Regards... and Wishing Good Practices... to All,

Pip01

[johnsog]

Our band is a very democratic bunch. Each year, in preparation for our annual meeting, we encourage all members to submit material they think would be suitable. We listen to them at the meeting, then vote on two or three we want to work on for the year, deciding when we want to have them ready (St. Pat's Day, St. Andrew's banquet). Our pipe major is pretty game and very seldom decrees a tune totally unsuitable. We have chosen some tunes that are great tunes but turn out to be challenging, causing some members to lose interest. Others turn out to be some that a few continue to work on and will perform as a small group. This may seem rather haphazard but it works for us.

[pancelticpiper]

Originally Posted by johnsog

we encourage all members to submit material they think would be suitable. We listen to them at the meeting, then vote on two or three...

Seems to me that choosing a tune for a lower-level band because it sounds great when you hear somebody playing it can be a recipe for trouble.

I've seen lower-level bands do that. They hear a great piper play the coolest tune in the world and get all fired up to have their band play it.

The trouble is, the fact that a great piper is playing and it's the coolest tune in the world practically guarantees that a lower-level band won't be able to play it well.

To know if a tune is suitable you have to play it. If a Pipe Major knows his Pipe Corps, knows that Piper A has trouble with low-hand work, knows that Piper B will have crossing noise problems with all those arpeggios, the Pipe Major can assess a tune's suitability.

I've seen Pipe Majors who are good at judging tunes' suitability for their band, and Pipe Majors who aren't. They foolishly pick tunes that are over the heads of everybody in the Pipe Corps except themselves, with predictable results in competition.

[EquusRacer]

Originally Posted by pancelticpiper

Seems to me that choosing a tune for a lower-level band because it sounds great when you hear somebody playing it can be a recipe for trouble.

I've seen lower-level bands do that. They hear a great piper play the coolest tune in the world and get all fired up to have their band play it.

The trouble is, the fact that a great piper is playing and it's the coolest tune in the world practically guarantees that a lower-level band won't be able to play it well.

To know if a tune is suitable you have to play it. If a Pipe Major knows his Pipe Corps, knows that Piper A has trouble with low-hand work, knows that Piper B will have crossing noise problems with all those arpeggios, the Pipe Major can assess a tune's suitability.

I've seen Pipe Majors who are good at judging tunes' suitability for their band, and Pipe Majors who aren't. They foolishly pick tunes that are over the heads of everybody in the Pipe Corps except themselves, with predictable results in competition.

I so totally agree! I, too, have witnessed this all too often.

Regarding being "democratic"; when I was P/M, I, too, invited tune submissions. However, I would determine if a tune was appropriate for our grade level (along with other criteria). I do remember one time when I was wanting to add a 2/4 march, and had members vote. HOWEVER, I worked with our lead stroke and picked out half a dozen that I felt were appropriate and for what we could get a good drum score. The members would vote on those, rather than getting a flood of proposals, many of which were not appropriate for our band's level.